Thursday, November 1, 2018

Introduction

This blog was designed to help people learn how to better find and evaluate moral arguments. The topic of homosexuality was used to give practical examples of moral arguments. This blog will help you to clearly understand how to properly form moral arguments, as well as learn the basic concepts of moral arguments. The methods and explanations in this blog will teach you how to properly think about moral issues.

We hope you enjoy this blog and learn a lot!

-Jaylen and Nicholas


Wednesday, October 31, 2018

Arguments against Homosexuality

If we are to assume the conclusion "homosexuality is wrong" then we must first explain what someone might mean by "homosexuality." When discussing homosexuality someone could be referring to:
Engaging in sexual activity with someone of the same sex
Having a romantic relationship with someone of the same sex
Having romantic feelings towards someone of the same sex
Behaving in a way, or "living a certain lifestyle" that is considered to be homosexual

So when we say that homosexuality is wrong we often refer to a particular set of actions that is to be considered wrong, or having a specific set of feelings towards someone of the same sex.

We will look at 5 premises that lead us to the conclusion that homosexuality is wrong:

Premise 1: Homosexuals can't reproduce

Conclusion: Homosexuality is wrong

In Premise 1 "homosexuality" refers to homosexual sexual activity

In order to connect premise 1 to the conclusion, you must create a linking premise which is a statement that explains the relationship between premise 1 and the conclusion.

Linking Premise 1: Any activity that cannot lead to reproduction is wrong.

So to place this argument into logically valid form would be to say:

Homosexual sexual activity can't lead to reproduction
Any activity that cannot lead to reproduction is wrong
Therefore, Homosexuality is wrong

Now that the argument is placed in a logically valid form you have to examine whether or not each premise is true.

Homosexuals can't reproduce:
-This premise is false because someone's sexual orientation has no bearing on whether or not they can reproduce.

Homosexual sexual activity can't lead to reproduction
-This premise is true

Any activity that cannot lead to reproduction is wrong
-There are many activities that cannot lead to reproduction such as reading or playing a xylophone.

Because neither premise is true we cannot say that the conclusion "Homosexuality is wrong" is true.
Meaning that this argument is not sound.

Premise 2: Homosexuals spread diseases

Conclusion: Homosexuality is wrong

In Premise 2 "homosexuality" refers to homosexual sexual activity

In order to connect premise 2 to the conclusion, you must create a linking premise which is a statement that explains the relationship between premise 2 and the conclusion.

Linking Premise 2: Any activity that spreads diseases is wrong

So to place this argument into logically valid form would be to say:

Homosexual sexual activity spread diseases
Any activity that spreads diseases is wrong
Therefore, Homosexuality is wrong

Now that the argument is placed in a logically valid form you have to examine whether or not each premise is true.

Homosexual sexual activity spread diseases:
-This premise needs to be clarified, if the premise is all homosexual sexual activity spread diseases then the premise would be false, because any sexual interaction between two healthy people of the same sex has no chance of spreading diseases.

Any activity that spreads diseases is wrong
-This statement is prima facie true because spreading diseases is generally considered to be wrong. 

Because the first premise is false we cannot say that the conclusion "Homosexuality is wrong" is true.
Meaning that this argument is not sound.

Premise 3: Homosexuality makes people feel uncomfortable

Conclusion: Homosexuality is wrong

In Premise 3 "homosexuality" can refer to certain stereotypical lifestyles or having a long term romantic relationship with someone of the same sex
  
In order to connect premise 3 to the conclusion, you must create a linking premise which is a statement that explains the relationship between premise 3 and the conclusion.

Linking Premise 3: Any activity that makes people feel uncomfortable is wrong.

So to place this argument into logically valid form would be to say:

Homosexuality makes people feel uncomfortable
Any activity that makes people feel uncomfortable is wrong.
Therefore, Homosexuality is wrong

Now that the argument is placed in a logically valid form you have to examine whether or not each premise is true.

Homosexuality makes people feel uncomfortable:
-This premise needs to be clarified, if it means homosexuality, as in certain stereotypical lifestyles or having a long term romantic relationship with someone of the same sex, makes some people feel uncomfortable then it is true, if it means all people then it is false.
  
Any activity that makes people feel uncomfortable is wrong.
-If we assume someone who uses this argument means anything that makes some people feel uncomfortable then we would have to conclude that it is false. Riding on rollercoasters or talking in front of crowds makes some people feel  uncomfortable 
but it isn't considered wrong.

Because the linking premise is false we cannot say that the conclusion "Homosexuality is wrong" is true.
Meaning that this argument is not sound.

Premise 4: Homosexuality is illegal

Conclusion: Homosexuality is wrong

In Premise 4 "homosexuality" refers to homosexual sexual activity or other certain behaviors or activities

In order to connect premise 4 to the conclusion, you must create a linking premise which is a statement that explains the relationship between premise 4 and the conclusion.

Linking Premise 4: Any activity that is illegal is wrong, or If something is illegal, then it is wrong

So to place this argument into logically valid form would be to say:

Homosexuality is illegal
If something is illegal, then it is wrong
Therefore, Homosexuality is wrong

Now that the argument is placed in a logically valid form you have to examine whether or not each premise is true.

Homosexuality is illegal
-This premise needs to be clarified, it is illegal in some countries but not in the united states, if the premise is that is illegal everywhere or in the united states then it is false. If it means that homosexuality is illegal in some places then it is true. 

If something is illegal (in some places), then it is wrong
-This premise is false, just because something is illegal or legal does not mean it is morally correct. For a long time slavery was legal in the united states but that does not make it right. It is also illegal for women to drive in some countries but that does not make it morally acceptable.  

Because neither premise is true we cannot say that the conclusion "Homosexuality is wrong" is true.
Meaning that this argument is not sound.

Premise 5: Homosexuality is a mental disorder

Conclusion: Homosexuality is wrong

In Premise 5 "homosexuality" refers to the attraction to someone of the same sex

In order to connect premise 5 to the conclusion, you must create a linking premise which is a statement that explains the relationship between premise 5 and the conclusion.

Linking Premise 5: If something is a mental disorder then it is wrong.

So to place this argument into logically valid form would be to say:

Homosexuality is a mental disorder
If something is a mental disorder, then it is wrong
Therefore, Homosexuality is wrong

Now that the argument is placed in a logically valid form you have to examine whether or not each premise is true.

Homosexuality is a mental disorder:
-This premise is false because there is no part of the brain that is tied to homosexuality. 

If something is a mental disorder, then it is wrong
-While someone who has a mental disorder has a brain that works differently it does not inherently mean something is wrong with them. There are people who have mental disorders but are still functioning and contributing members of society. Almost 1 in 12 adults are reported to have depression which is a mental disorder but they are not inherently to be considered "wrong."

Because neither premise is true we cannot say that the conclusion "Homosexuality is wrong" is true.
Meaning that this argument is not sound.

Evaluating Moral Arguments

There are two important questions that should be asked when thinking about moral issues:

Those two questions are WHY THINK THAT? ("Why" is the premise and "that" is the conclusion and WHAT DO YOU MEAN? (understanding what the person is tying to argue is crucial) 

Premise: A premise is a statement that justifies a conclusion 

Conclsion: A conclusion is a decision that is reached by reasoning

An ARGUMENT is a conclsusion that is supported by a premise or premsies

If an action is morally obligatory, it means that the action must be done

If an action is morally permissible, it means that it is okay to do or to not do

If an action is morally wrong, it means that it is not okay to do

A logically valid argument is an argument that has premises that lead to the conlcusion

A sound argument is a logically valid argument that has true premsies that lead to a true conclusion

Essentially, a sound argument has to stem from at least two true premises

The premises that are used in moral arugments can be facutal or scientific premises or general moral principles 

A general moral principle is a principal that is uncontroversially accepted

Counterexample: An example which disproves a proposition 

There are different types of argument patterns:

Simple syllogism: A is an X; all X's are Y's; Therefore, A is Y

Modus Ponens: If P, then Q; P; Therefore Q

Modus Tollens: If P, then Q; Not Q; Therefore, not P

Question Begging Arguments: A question begging argument is an argument that assumes that the conclusion is in the premise




Sunday, October 28, 2018

Conclusion

We hope that this blog has taught you how to form moral arguments, as well as teach you the main concepts of moral arguments. We hope that this blog has helped you to better find and evaluate moral arguments as well. The topic that was used in moral arguments for this blog was homosexuality, but these skills can be applied to any other moral arguments. We hope that you have learned a lot from this blog!

Thank you for visiting

Introduction

This blog was designed to help people learn how to better find and evaluate moral arguments. The topic of homosexuality was used to give pra...